Review of “The Legend of the Light Keeper” by Kelly Hall

25081972I really like fictional stories that play off of real legends, and apparently this is one. The whole history of Bragg’s legend was really interesting to me, and I liked the paranormal/ghost story twist that the author used.

In typical YA fashion, we meet the heroine as she’s adapting to a major life change. Then cute boys are throw in.  THEN, the story gets interesting when they start to explore the mysteries of the Light.  I thought the use of the Granny character was really smart, giving the author a way to tell some history stories without drawing away from the present setting.  Then the use of the diary to really flesh out the backstory made me go “Oh!” as a whole new layer was added.  That’s when the book really picked up for me and I got sucked into the mystery of figuring out what the Light was all about and why Lily was connected.

However, there were a few hiccups for me.  The weird love triangle where Lily quickly falls for her soon-to-be step-brother really was a little off-putting for me.  It seems to me that it would’ve worked just fine for them to develop a brother-sister relationship (which could have been quite touching too, if in a different way).  She could’ve just as easily developed feelings for Owen, and THAT turns out to be forbidden too… I don’t know.  I’m usually pretty picky about how any romance is used in a story, but this was a little weird for me.

I also found the mother character very lacking.  She and Tom (the soon-to-be step-father) are barely present in the story, which is something you see all too often in YA, I think.  Her mom seems like kind a flake, even working through her daughter’s 16th birthday when this poor girl clearly needs time with her mom.  So there’s that.

Also, Lily is often put in the place of a girly, weak, helpless damsel.  It happens over and over and over again.  Sometimes she stands up for herself and insists that the boys include her or take her seriously.  Sometimes she realizes she’s acting childish.  But most of the time, she is the girl with the girl jobs; they are the boys who are strong and in charge.

BUT, it is a quick, fun read.  The writing itself is very YA — not too complicated, with simple language used.  There’s certainly enough romance to keep readers of Lily’s age engrossed.   I think adults will also like this if you’re looking for a lot of mystery to figure out, and the action sections are very entertaining.  It’s a very well-edited book, so that helps a lot in feeling like the book is of good, objective quality.

Definitely worth a read if you’re looking for a quick, YA ghost story.

3.5 Stars See it on Amazon!

About Sunshine Somerville

I'm the author of "The Kota Series" and "A Fairly Fairy Tale. Originally from the beach side of Michigan, I work as a medical transcriptionist from home. When not staring into a computer screen, I enjoy reading, painting, and being outdoors.
This entry was posted in Reading, review and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply